|
Computer
speaker systems have brought a new element to the computing experience.
Though they may be a form of analog technology, they are not yet archaic
or outdated. Instead, speakers serve to merge the digital world to
the sensory world that we live in. Ultimately, they have served as a
catalyst for multimedia computing—what good would an MP3 or webcast be
with just subtitles?
Our
society has been bred on television as a medium. Integrated video
and audio is a standard set in our childhood that is now fueling a
bandwidth hunger via the Internet. As a result, computer speakers
are as important as the monitor in our computing environment. The
growth of computer audio has also resulted in more choices in size,
styling, and format of speaker systems. The challenge is to find a
high quality speaker system that will heighten the computer experience
through quality and power, instead of an ill chosen system that holds back
the entire computer
The
Decibel
Before
jumping directly into the technical nitty gritty, some explanation of
the measurement standards used in audio is necessary. For everyone
that knows the difference between dBm and dB SPL, and especially how
they relate to the audio industry, feel free to skip directly to the
specification breakdown. Audio specifications are not exactly
transfer rates or IP addresses, so some background can be helpful.
The
key unit in audio is the decibel. Technically one tenth of a Bell
(yes, it is named after Alexander Graham Bell, and carries the
capitalization when abbreviated), it is a logarithmic scale that compares
two power quantities. Logarithmic, besides being a hard word to
spell, is a technique used when relatively large quantities, such as 10
and 1000 for example, are compared to each other. A logarithmic
scale compare the difference based on the ratio of the second quantity
to the first instead of the difference between the two as in a linear
scale. Figure 1 demonstrates the logarithmic curve of the decibel
scale; note that it does not follow a straight line. In the dB
scale, a change from 1 watt to 100 watts would be measured the same as a
change from 10 watts to 1000 watts because it compares the first value
to the second. Both changes would be measured as 20 dB (see the
equations below).
Because
the dB is a measurement based in comparison, it can be used in various
applications. In audio, the two primary comparisons are made with
power and force. The electric power in a system typically is
measured against a reference level of one milliwatt (.001 watt).
Though it may seem arbitrary, this level comes out of standards for
interconnections and the corresponding powers dating back to the early
era of radio, first set forward in 1940. The equation that
dictates decibels measuring power is dB = 10 * log (P1/P2).
If you work the math, this means that twice the power results in a 3 dB
difference, so specifications dealing with audio signal power are
dictated by this rule of three- 3 dBm = 2x the power.
The
electrical analogy of a speaker’s air movement (what makes the sound),
is voltage in a circuit. As the human senses are logarithmic, it
is convenient to continue to use the decibel scale when describing
speaker volume. However, because the analogy is to voltage and not
power, the Bell equation must be slightly modified. Power is
related to voltage by the equation P = E2/R.
Substituting this into the earlier equation, and moving the exponent to
outside the log results in the equation for comparing Sound Pressure
Levels (SPL): dB SPL = 20 log (E1/E2). The
reference level (0 dB SPL) used for the scale is the threshold of
hearing for a youngster (before the heavy metal music that starts to
kill his or her ears). The threshold of pain is about 120 dB.
As this equation has been slightly modified, twice the SPL equals a 6 dB
difference. Therefore, the sound pressure levels in speakers
are dictated by a rule of six: 6 dB SPL= 2x the sound pressure.
As a note, the human body perceives about 10dB SPL to be twice as
loud—again, the body acts as a logarithmic scale.
Well,
enough of the math review. Let’s dive into the specifications
and find out what’s really going on in the speakers.
Speaker
Specifications: How to read between the lines
Before
listening to any speaker
system, the manufacturer’s specifications provide a basis for
comparison. Through a variety of tests to determine the sonic
quality and electrical characteristics of the speakers, manufacturers
determine the numbers intended to reveal the performance of their systems.
However, results can, and often are, presented in an ambiguous manner that
appears to enhance the specs of a system. In order to reveal these
possibilities, careful examination of each specification is necessary.
·
Drivers: The actual speakers used in the
cabinet. The physical components of a speaker are fairly simple.
The cabinet, or enclosure, is the wood or plastic box that contains the
drivers, or speakers, and the electronics involved in making the sound,
such as an amplifier and crossover networks. This specification
indicates the size and type of transducers (speakers) used.
The number of
drivers is very revealing as to the nature of the speaker system. When
there are more speakers, they can be tailored to fit particular sound
spectrums as each component handles just part of the frequency range. In a
two way system, low and mid frequencies are reproduced by the woofer while
a tweeter reproduces the highs. A three way system is when a
subwoofer reproduces the lowest frequencies, a mid range woofer powers the
intermediate frequencies, and the tweeter provides the high frequencies.
When a transducer handles a smaller frequency band, it can handle higher
levels of power; sound is energy and if they are reproducing a more
limited range of energy, they can handle higher levels.
In these multi
speaker units, a crossover network
is used to split the sound spectrum and route the parts to the appropriate
speaker. The crossover can also control the relative output levels
for the speakers, actually balancing the sound across the frequency
spectrum. Most importantly, they are set so as not to overwork the
speakers and shorten their life spans by sending high energy frequencies
to speakers not designed to handle them.
Here is a breakdown
on the components often used in speaker systems. Through a
combination of these components, a speaker is able to reproduce the full
(or almost full) spectrum of sound.
o
Tweeters are used for high frequency sound, usually sounds
over 1.5 kHz. A smaller transducer can reproduce high frequency
sound. Compression drivers and piezoelectric transducers can also
serve as tweeters in a speaker system.
o
Woofers are used for low frequency sound reproduction up
to around 1.5 kHz. Because low frequencies have a longer
wavelength, woofers must be larger in order to move the air volume
necessary to reproduce these lower frequencies. As a result, the
larger a woofer, the more power it can carry, and the louder the bass
will be. In addition, for all the rumbling low frequency noise,
the body senses the energy as much as feels it. When used for both
low and mid frequency sound, woofer will produce sounds up to around 1.5
kHz
o
Sub woofers are use to reproduce the lowest frequencies,
usually up to 500 Hz. These provide the rumble element to the
sound system as they move the most air and shake the body as much as the
eardrums. The larger the sub woofer driver, the more energy it can
handle, and the more impressive it can
Frequency
Response: How much and how accurately the speakers can reproduce
the sound spectrum. The response is measured using an analyzer that
reads the speaker’s reproduction of a standard audio test signal.
Human hearing spans
the frequency response of 20 Hz to 20 kHz, and in an ideal world, a
speaker would reproduce all of these frequencies. Unfortunately,
when indicating the frequency response of speakers, manufacturers often
fail to tell the whole truth. If they do not indicate how accurate
the speaker response is, specs can often look far better than the speaker
actually sounds.
The simple
description of frequency response of 20 Hz to 20 kHz would seem ideal;
however, this is a true statement even if the sound at 20 Hz is 40 dB SPL
lower than the sound at 1.2 kHz. This means that the lowest bass
frequency is a hundred times less powerful than an average midrange
frequency— i.e. the speaker may reproduce all of those frequencies but
nowhere near at the same level.
A much more clear
method of specifying frequency response involves giving a tolerance, the
range within which the speaker produces all of the frequencies within its
frequency response range. For example, a frequency response of
20 Hz to 20 kHz +/- 3 dB indicates a much superior speaker to the one
mentioned earlier with a bass roll off of 40 dB. Basically, the
latter speaker maintains its level all the way into its lowest frequency,
while the former just goes away (rolls off) in its lower frequencies.
The lowest bass frequency is at most only half of what a typical mid range
frequency is reproduced at. Without indicating the tolerance on the
specifications, companies can create extremely misleading specifications.
Impedance: Technically, impedance is the opposition to
current flow in an alternating current circuit. Its significance in
audio is a way to ensure that components work together correctly; the
audio input needs to use up the current from an output circuit.
Typically,
input impedances are higher than the output impedance of the circuit they
are connected to. So, a powered speaker system is taking in a line
level input and should have high impedance.
·
S/N Ratio: The difference between the nominal program
level, or speaker volume, and the noise floor, or underlying hiss and
static in an electronic circuit. The larger the S/N ratio, the
better.
Higher
S/N will be very noticeable. The sound will be cleaner with less
noise during playback, and when the speakers are turned on but not in use,
quieter with less residual hiss. For critical listeners, this
specification should carry some weight. If your music, or games,
have a broad dynamic range (the difference between the loudest and
quietest portions of the program), it is very important to insure that the
S/N ratio is larger than this dynamic range. If is not, then either
the quietest portion will be lost beneath the hiss of the noise floor, or
the loudest portions will overload the speakers and cause clipping and
distortion. Either way, the listening environment will not be
satisfactory and deduct from your overall computing experience.
·
Output Power: How much power the amplifier provides
to the speaker system. The amplifier is often integrated into one or
all of the speakers in a configuration known as “powered speakers,” as
opposed to having an independent amplifier like in a home stereo system.
A larger output power will directly lead to a louder speaker system.
Also, in a multichannel system, the principal stereo speakers should be
more powerful than the surround speakers, which are just used for spatial
effects. Finally, in a sub woofer, higher powers will lead to a
punchier system with more presence. When examining speaker’s
handling of power, sometimes the speaker’s efficiency is presented.
As a speaker is a transducer, its job is to convert forms of energy, from
electrical to physical movement of the air. The efficiency measure
how much energy is actually transformed instead of lost to heat.
Given two equal speakers, one with a higher efficiency will attain higher
volume levels at lower power and will perform better than the less
efficient speaker.
The
trick with output power is how it is measured. When not indicating
the standard used in measuring, any specification talking about output
power can be deceitful. The most common, and fairly honest, standard
is to use the RMS (root mean square) testing method. This technique
takes the average of an alternating current signal, such as the power sent
to speakers, and gives a specification that would be equivalent to the
power dissipated in a comparable direct current circuit. If a
company chooses to instead list peak power, this doesn’t always reveal
the full truth of the speaker. Sound is produced by alternating
current with ever-changing levels, and the RMS value gives a much better
idea of what the system can really do, instead of the instantaneous peaks
in power. Some other methods, such as describing “music power”
or “program power” will vary based on the signal used to create the
specification and can prove to be more deceptive, yielding higher ratings
than the actual performance in normal listening conditions.
Another
specification bundled into output power is the Total Harmonic Distortion,
or THD. This is a measurement of the purity of the audio signal.
Like digital artifacts in imaging, electronic equipment can introduce
distortion in the form of harmonics, or frequencies not present in the
source, but reproduced as integer multiples of the source frequency (i.e.
a 100Hz source produces an output with 100, 200, 200 Hz and so on).
Besides the loss of quality, the human ear is bothered by these
imperfections. The distortion can be presented in either of two
ways—by presenting the difference in signal between source and harmonics
in dB, or by giving a percentage to indicate the ratio between the
harmonics and the original source. Therefore, the lower of either
two numbers, the higher quality of the audio. Given a typical
reading of so and so watts at 0.1% THD, this means that the artifacts are
going to be 1/1000th of the program level, or 30 dB lower.
Translated into speaker pressure, that’s 1/64th of the
program source in perceived loudness. What does this all mean?
If the program’s dynamic range is greater than 30 dB, then the harmonics
are going to be evident in the program as they fall within the dynamic
range. However, the dynamics would be present within the range only
under the loudest portions, which would drown them out. This makes
0.1% THD reasonable, but a lower value would mean a better speaker.
When
these specifications are tested, there is a quick way and there is a
thorough way; the two don’t go together. When checking distortion,
it is possible to examine just one frequency and how the system reacts to
it, or to look at the full spectrum and present the system’s overall
distortion. THD across the entire spectrum will indicate a more
accurate picture of the speaker’s quality. And seeing as sound is
much more than just a test tone, this gives a more accurate picture of how
well the speakers will actually sound. Also, computer
manufacturers aren’t subjected to the requirement to present all of
their specifications from stereo mode, like on home receivers. So
their measuring environment may not resemble an actual listening
environment; instead it may be optimized for good specs.
Makes Available For Speakers
| Altec Lansing |
Aztec |
Champion |
| Creative |
Decible |
Foxen |
| Gemini |
Honda |
Impulse |
| Microtek |
Samsung |
Yamaha |
| Maxcom |
Microtek |
Alnova |
|